Last week, Christian social media was ablaze with the latest ecclesiastical controversy. Forget yoga pants, women pastors, or which “Christian” (if they can even call themselves that!) charity we should be avoiding this week. Last week the hot topic was spouses sitting together in church. 😱
The online brouhaha started with a Gospel Coalition Australia article by Dave Moore, provocatively titled “Spouses Please Stop Sitting Together”. Queue outrage machine!
Having recently deleted my Twitter account, I was spared from much of the silliness that ensued. However, over on Facebook (Twitter for oldies) the discussion continued amongst the Aussies with a rebuttal piece from Stephen McAlpine entitled “Spouses, Sit Together at Church”, and a weighing in from The (O.G. United States) Gospel Coalition by Griffin Gulledge, “When Families Sit Together in Church: The Missional Opportunity”.
When I pitched this topic to Joel McMaster for The Shock Absorber, he thought the idea was ridiculous! Why were Christians even debating this in the first place? Sit with your spouse; don’t sit with your spouse. Aren’t there more important things to talk about and have concern for?
Certainly!
And yet… there is also something non-trivial in the debates. It seems to me that we are arguing about something significant: the theological distinction between our temporal and temporary families in creation, and our eternal family made up of brothers and sisters in Christ living as New Creation.
There is a significant shift between the Old Testament and the New when it comes to family. As I wrote in my chapter of Parenting in God’s Family: Vol. 2,
Suddenly, it is not biology and Jewish lineage that are the most important factors in defining ‘family’. Family is reconfigured to mean those who are faithful to Jesus and his teaching. Even more confronting, Jesus tells his disciples that the prerequisite for following him is ‘hating’ their own biological family because division among household members is part and parcel of his coming (Luke 14:26–27). Richard Melick Jr. notes that ‘the Gospels reveal a higher concern than family. The kingdom of God must have top priority’.
Jesus does not erode all care and responsibility for family, but he relativises the household within the ‘family of God’…
Similarly, Paul, in his household codes, expresses an ongoing responsibility of parents towards their children, and children towards their parents (Ephesians 6:1–4; Colossians 3:20–21), yet also continues to foster Jesus’ vision that the true family to which we belong is the household of faith (Galatians 6:10; 1 Timothy 3:14–15). The other New Testament epistle authors also use the language of ‘brothers and sisters’ as a reference to other Christians (for example, Hebrews 2:11; James 1:2; 2 Peter 1:10; 1 John 3:13).
This language is more than a mere nicety. In the ancient world, the strongest social connection was between siblings—greater than that between parent–child or husband–wife. Conceiving of church as family, and fellow Christians as brothers and sisters, is a radical restructuring of the social world so that those who share faith in Christ have the greatest claim on the Christian’s time, care, attention and affection.
This is what I believe is at the heart of the disagreement. Does my spouse have priority over my time, care, attention and affection? In much of our life together, emphatically yes! But something strange happens when we gather as the people of God. It is not just the practicalities of one or both of us serving in different areas of the church that prevent us from sitting together as much as we may like. It is also because, especially in that hour of gathered worship and the hours of community that surround it, the foremost relationship I share with my wife is not spouse, but brother and sister in Christ. And if that is true, then that is the same relationship I share with all the other brothers and sisters who gather in our all-age, all-stage community on a Sunday morning. And especially in those hours, there may be other brothers and sisters in my community who are in greater need of my time, care, attention and affection.
The foremost relationship I share with my wife is not spouse,
but brother and sister in Christ.
That is why you will likely not see my wife and I sitting together at church, though at other times you will.
It is also why, if I were to pick sides in this debate, I had no issues with Moore’s original article and (after we had finished recording) I appreciated MURRAY CAMPBELL’s excellent follow-up piece.
You can catch the full conversation, including a further conversation about why it is so hard to have a nuanced conversation and hold cognitive dissonance in our minds, in the links below or on your favourite podcast app.

